Establishing Bias Of An Informant With Active Listening – In The Moment

I’ve always preached that you have to be “in the moment” when cross examining a witness.  While its okay to have notes and an outline, you must listen to the witness in real time and react to what he/she says.  In a recent case in which I cross examined an informant, the witness let slip a single word, “we” during my cross examination of him.  This single word revealed just how biased he was.  More importantly, I caught it because I was listening and I used it as a dagger against him and the state:

Establishing Bias - Informant

Notice how he uttered the word “we” while trying to explain something:

… they have a protocol just like we did

I heard it and I pounced:

Q: When you say “we”, you’re referring to the police department?

A: Yes.

Q: The people you were working with?

A: Yes.

Q: You’re (sic) partners in this case?

A: Yes.

With the utterance of a single word, “we”, I got the witness to admit that he and the police were partners.  Partners!

This was only possible because I was listening to the testimony and reacting in real time.  This is killer cross examination.

Tags: , , , , ,